YougeneDebs's videos on livevideo

H2 DEBUNK PROPAGANDA911

rss@LiveVideo.com (YougeneDebs) — Sat, 24 Oct 2009 10:39:05 GMT

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to my first ‘How To’ video! Today I’ll show how to debunk Simon Shack’s video “PROPAGANDA911” in one easy mouse click. That’s right, just one mouse click is all it takes. But first, there is an aspect of Simon’s “PROPAGANDA911” that deserves our attention. It concerns Hollywood’s effect on the evidence. And by Hollywood, I mean the entertainment industry, in general. Hollywood doesn’t view the archival record as evidence, like most of us do; to Hollywood, it’s just so much raw material for their production! They are allowed to take what ever footage they can get and slice it, dice it, mix’n’match it; strip the audio track out of it and insert whatever they please. My point here is that as we build our case, we should rest it on fact, not Hollywood; and use primary source material whenever possible. And on this point “PROPAGANDA911” fails in some parts because Simon has simply made a movie review; a review of the film “THE 9-11 HOTEL”. For instance, Simon compares a picture that HOTEL attributes to the Sweeting family with the well-known Rob Howard photograph. Simon did well to point out the similarities and demonstrate that he is capable of doing research. But even if the makers of “HOTEL” confess that they switched out the Sweeting picture for Howard’s photo, all Simon has is a piece of their poetic license; and they’ve got lawyers. On the other hand, if Simon rests his claim that the Sweeting family is fake simply because “HOTEL” used the Rob Howard photograph, Simon is likely to come up short and for the same reason – poetic license! If Simon wants to demonstrate that someone is fake, he’s going to have to come up with at least one hard fact. And on this point, Simon is successful – he does find one hard fact. In “HOTEL”, Ronnie Clifford describes how he helped a burn victim Julie Ann Maffeo; giving her aid and comfort, helping her to an ambulance, and that she hung on to dear life in hospital for some 40 days before giving up the struggle. Enter Simon Shack. Simon does some research and finds an archived web story by the BBC dated September 12, 2001. In that story, the BBC interviews John Clifford, the brother of Ronnie Clifford. Brother John is quoted as saying: “She subsequently died.” Simon Shack notes the difference of some 39 days and hangs his hat on this apparent contradiction as if it supports his spectacular claims of Fakery. Well, I have to admit that I was shocked! And I had to remind myself that even a broken clock is right twice a day. I went straight to the BBC web site and called up the story and read it for myself, just to make sure everything was cricket; same date, same headline, same picture, same text; even the same quote. Could Simon have actually found something? Alas, No. There is something visible on the web page that is not visible in Simon’s graphic. Heading the side bar on the right is a link to a video interview with Brother John and all one needs to do, in order to debunk Simon Shack’s “PROPAGANDA911” is click on it. Let’s watch the interview and listen to the spoken words of John Clifford: And there we have it: John Clifford was simply miss-quoted. Saying “I think she subsequently died,” is merely expressing an opinion and does not contradict the statement made by Ronnie Clifford. The apparent contradiction simply evaporates carrying along with it Simon’s only tangible support for Fakery. It’s back to the drawing board for Simon Shack and I’d like to wish him Good Luck. And that concludes this presentation on how to debunk Simon Shack’s “PROPAGANDA911” in one easy mouse click. Special thanks to Matt for the BBC clip! Thanks to all of you for tuning in. Be well and Godspeed. End credit music “Utru Horas” by Orchestra Baobab http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/northern_ireland/1540529.stm

Author: YougeneDebs
Keywords: Septemberclues.info simon shack propaganda911 hotel wtc nyc matt sweeting howard socialservice terror bunk debunk hollywood
Added: Sat, 24 Oct 2009 10:39:05 GMT